Blog

17 November, 2026

Why EDCI is becoming more than a reporting exercise

Calm Ocean At Sunset Pink Skies

Sustainability reporting in private markets is no longer only about collecting more data.

The bigger challenge is ensuring that the data collected across portfolio companies is consistent, comparable, and useful for decision-making.

Portfolio companies often receive multiple sustainability data requests from different stakeholders. While these requests may seek similar information, they can vary across methodologies, definitions, reporting boundaries, and submission formats. This creates a fragmented reporting landscape, where large volumes of data may be collected, but comparing performance across companies or developing a meaningful portfolio-level view remains challenging.

This is the challenge that led to the development of the ESG Data Convergence Initiative (“EDCI”). By establishing a common set of sustainability reporting metrics, EDCI aims to bring greater consistency to data collection across private markets. In practice, this enables investors to spend less time reconciling different reporting approaches and more time identifying trends, assessing performance, and understanding how sustainability initiatives may contribute to portfolio outcomes.

As firms begin planning for the 2027 EDCI reporting cycle, early preparation will be increasingly important. Effective implementation depends not only on collecting sustainability data, but also on ensuring that the information is reliable, complete, and ready to support portfolio-level analysis. EDCI currently focuses on core sustainability indicators across areas such as greenhouse gas emissions, net zero commitment, renewable energy, board and C-suite diversity, work-related accidents, net new hires, and employee engagement. These metrics provide a common reporting foundation, but practical implementation has shown that governance, validation processes, and portfolio company engagement remain critical to producing meaningful insights.

What EDCI implementation is revealing across portfolios

As more private market firms implement EDCI across their portfolios, a clear lesson is emerging: collecting responses is only the starting point. The more complex work often begins when investors assess whether the reported information is consistent, sufficiently supported, and suitable for comparison across portfolio companies.

While portfolio companies may report against the same EDCI metrics, the underlying methodologies, assumptions, reporting boundaries, and supporting documentation can vary significantly. This means investors often need to undertake additional work before portfolio-wide assessments can begin, including clarifying calculation approaches, reviewing evidence, identifying outliers, and resolving inconsistencies across submissions. Without this review process, metrics that appear comparable on the surface may not always provide a reliable basis for informed decision-making.

Across recent EDCI implementation cycles, several practical lessons have emerged:

  • Large portfolios often require significant clarification before meaningful analysis can begin. In one portfolio of more than 200 companies, the main challenge is often not simply collecting responses, but resolving differences in calculation approaches, reporting boundaries, and supporting evidence before the information can be used consistently.

  • Smaller portfolios can still face meaningful validation challenges. Even in portfolios with under 20 companies, differences in internal ownership, source documentation, and reporting maturity can create inconsistencies that need to be addressed before submission.

  • Company size does not necessarily predict reporting readiness. Some smaller companies may have well-defined processes and clear ownership, while larger companies may rely on more fragmented systems, decentralised inputs, or less formali sustainability reporting practices.

  • Early validation reduces downstream friction. Identifying methodology questions, missing evidence, and outliers before submission can reduce repeated follow-ups, improve confidence in the final dataset, and support more informed portfolio assessments.

Key lessons for private market firms

Starting early is critical. Firms that identify data gaps, clarify methodologies, and review calculations at the beginning of the reporting process are better positioned to reduce challenges during submission and improve confidence in reported outcomes.

EDCI implementation has also demonstrated that a one-size-fits-all approach is often ineffective across diverse portfolios. Portfolio companies vary considerably in their reporting maturity, internal resources, data systems, and familiarity with sustainability reporting requirements. As a result, investors may need to provide tailored support, including calculation guidance, evidence requirements, and regular communication throughout the reporting cycle.

How firms can get more value from EDCI reporting

The firms deriving the greatest benefit from EDCI reporting tend to treat it as an ongoing portfolio monitoring process rather than a periodic reporting requirement. Establishing clear ownership for sustainability metrics, methodologies, and reporting responsibilities can help improve both reporting efficiency and overall consistency.

Providing portfolio companies with clear guidance upfront is also essential. When companies understand how metrics should be calculated, what supporting information is required, and how the data will be used, submissions are generally more consistent and require fewer revisions. Training, knowledge sharing, and regular engagement can also help portfolio companies strengthen their reporting capability over time.

Leading firms are also moving beyond compliance-focused reporting and using EDCI data to inform broader portfolio management discussions. By connecting sustainability metrics with operational performance indicators, investors can identify emerging trends and areas for targeted engagement. For example, emissions and energy data may highlight opportunities to improve resource efficiency, while workforce and employee engagement metrics can provide insights into company stability and workforce effectiveness.

Moving from reporting to decision-making

As sustainability reporting expectations continue to evolve across private markets, EDCI is helping establish a more consistent framework for sustainability measurement and reporting. By encouraging the use of common metrics across portfolios, it supports more structured sustainability discussions between investors and portfolio companies and helps improve transparency across investment portfolios.

Firms that integrate EDCI into broader portfolio oversight processes are likely to be better positioned to strengthen reporting readiness, improve investor engagement, and develop a more comprehensive understanding of sustainability performance across their investments. As reporting expectations continue to mature, EDCI can serve as an important foundation for more informed portfolio engagement and oversight within private markets.

As private market firms prepare for the 2027 EDCI reporting cycle, we support investors with portfolio company engagement, EDCI data collection, pre-submission validation, and post-submission analysis to help turn reporting outputs into more decision-useful portfolio insights.

Link copied to clipboard